The cognitive benefits of chess, and what the research really says
Posted
"Chess makes kids smarter" is one of the most repeated claims in the game. Is it true? Partly, in a smaller and less certain way than the posters say, and the real picture is more interesting than the slogan.
What the research finds
Stronger players tend to score somewhat higher on some thinking tests. A meta-analysis by Burgoyne and colleagues (2016, Intelligence) pooled studies of chess skill and cognitive ability. A 2018 corrigendum fixed an error in how some of the data were weighted and put the average correlation at about 0.22 (first reported as 0.24): statistically significant, but modest. After the correction, links with fluid reasoning and short-term or working memory still held. Links with crystallised knowledge and processing speed were no longer significant. This is a correlation, so it cannot say whether chess builds these skills or people who have them take to chess.
Teaching chess to children: the better-controlled studies find little or no gain in school results. A 2016 meta-analysis by Sala and Gobet (Educational Research Review) pooled 24 studies and found a moderate average effect (g = 0.34), larger for maths than for reading. Nearly all of those studies lacked an "active" control group doing some other activity, so the authors could not rule out the effects of enthusiasm, teacher expectations or novelty. In two later experiments with active comparison groups (checkers, or Go), Sala and Gobet (2017) found no statistically significant difference in maths problem solving. And a randomised trial of more than 4,000 children in England (Jerrim and colleagues, 2018) found no evidence that chess lessons changed maths, reading or science test scores.
Board games and older age. A 2003 study by Verghese and colleagues (New England Journal of Medicine) followed 469 community-dwelling adults over 75 for a median of 5.1 years. Those who played board games, read, played musical instruments or danced had a lower risk of dementia. It was observational, board games were one activity among several (not chess alone), and the authors called for controlled trials to find out whether such activities actually protect.
What that means in plain words
- Chess is a demanding mental activity, and strong players tend to do a little better on certain tests.
- Nobody can honestly promise that learning chess will raise grades or protect your memory.
- What you do get is practice at chess: weighing options, calculating ahead and finishing a game you are losing. Whether those habits spread to the rest of life is what the research has not settled.
The benefit nobody argues about
Here is the part that holds up without any meta-analysis. Playing in person is social. A club gives you a regular evening, opponents who get to know your style, and a reason to look forward to Thursday. For children it is also a structured place to practise sitting with a problem, and for adults a low-pressure way to keep a lifelong habit.
How to find your club
Search the ChessOS club finder by town or ZIP code, use your location, or browse by state. Some clubs run their own ChessOS site, where you can see the real schedule, follow events and register for tournaments. Others are listed from public sources such as state chess federations' club lists, so check the schedule with the club before you go. Joining is usually as simple as showing up to a club meeting.
If you run a club
Make it easy for newcomers to find you. A clear meeting time, an address and a "come and try" line on your site matter more than any research citation. Our guide to creating a club website with Quick start shows how to have one up quickly.
Sources
- Burgoyne AP, Sala G, Gobet F, Macnamara BN, Campitelli G, Hambrick DZ, 2016. The relationship between cognitive ability and chess skill: a comprehensive meta-analysis. Intelligence 59, 72-83.
- Burgoyne AP et al., 2018. Corrigendum to the above. Intelligence 71, 92-96.
- Sala G, Gobet F, 2016. Do the benefits of chess instruction transfer to academic and cognitive skills? A meta-analysis. Educational Research Review 18, 46-57.
- Sala G, Gobet F, 2017. Does chess instruction improve mathematical problem-solving ability? Two experimental studies with an active control group. Learning & Behavior 45(4), 414-421.
- Jerrim J, Macmillan L, Micklewright J, Sawtell M, Wiggins M, 2018. Does teaching children how to play cognitively demanding games improve their educational attainment? Evidence from a randomized controlled trial of chess instruction in England. Journal of Human Resources 53(4), 993-1021.
- Verghese J, Lipton RB, Katz MJ, et al., 2003. Leisure activities and the risk of dementia in the elderly. New England Journal of Medicine 348(25), 2508-2516.
Next step: Find a chess club near you, pick an evening, and go along. Whatever the research says about brains, you will meet people who love the game.